Showing posts with label Gloucester County. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gloucester County. Show all posts

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Gloucester citizens appeal to VA Supreme Court

~Citizens fined for trying to remove county supervisors~

A group of 40 Gloucester County citizens, upset at what they considered unjust real estate assessments, circulated petitions in 2008 to have county supervisors removed from their jobs. The Washington Examiner reported that a County judge fined them $2,000 each:
The 40 Gloucester residents circulated petitions in 2008 to have members of the county board of supervisors removed from office after several were indicted on charges of meeting in secret.

Substitute Circuit Judge Westbrook Parker dismissed the charges and the removal petitions and assessed the fines after ruling the residents were politically motivated. The fines are intended to defray the supervisors' legal expenses.

"I've never seen the judicial system abused so much for purely political ends," Parker said in his ruling. "This should not happen in America."
I respectfully disagree with Judge Parker because, what "should not happen in America," is judges and elected representatives fining American citizens for daring to question their elected officials, as guaranteed in the First Amendment.

This is reminiscent of the real estate assessment battle currently going on in Augusta County where citizens and their lone pro bono lawyer are being crushed by the local government and sanctioned by a local judge ...

... where 600 citizens turned out on February 3, 2009, to hear how to fight back against high real estate assessments ... where 10,600 citizens signed petitions asking the Augusta Board of Supervisors to roll back assessments ...where over 1,000 -- the largest crowd ever -- turned out for a supervisor meeting on March 18, 2009, to protest those high assessments. They were met with arrogance and lectures from their elected representatives.

It would be good to see the 40 citizens from Gloucester successful in their appeal before the Virginia Supreme Court. It would restore their faith in government for many.

Monday, April 20, 2009

Gloucester judge shuts down petitioners who tried to remove supervisors

Before the real estate assessment protest in Augusta County, there was a similar movement in Gloucester County. Residents circulated petitions for removal of supervisors and filed with the court only to be slapped with fines of $2,000 each by Circuit Court Judge Westbrook J. Parker.

The First Amendment allows the right of the people to petition the government for a redress of grievances. Many felt that Judge Parker's ruling smacked down the First Amendment.

Now that same judge has done it again:
Circuit Court Judge Westbrook J. Parker rejected 40 Gloucester County petitioners' attempt to reverse a controversial order that critics say upends the First Amendment.Parker fined the petitioners $2,000 each in December. The $80,000 would cover part of $129,321 in attorney fees and court costs awarded to four county supervisors who had faced petitions to remove them office, after the effort was thrown out of court.

L. Steven Emmert, the petitioners' attorney, requested a hearing to argue the petitioners weren't represented in court the day they were fined. Parker agreed last month to a hearing but only to allow Emmert to provide evidence why the petitioners shouldn't be fined.

The judge rescinded the offer because the petitioners "do not want to present any evidence" to support their cause, according to documents filed Friday in Gloucester County Circuit Court.
...
Last month, Parker wrote the petitioners would be allowed to testify to their basis of filing the petitions and who guided them in the process.

The latter issue has been of interest to defense attorneys who speculate that attorneys aided the petitioners but are unwilling to come forward out of fear of being sanctioned.
Interesting speculation considering the same has been whispered in Augusta County. The article concluded:
The case has drawn interest across the state and beyond because critics of Parker's initial ruling say it violates the First Amendment, which allows citizens to petition the government for redress of grievances.
If that right is taken away, the republic will be gone.

Update: Rick Sincere pointed out that Judge Westbrook J. Parker was the recipient of a 2009 Thomas Jefferson Muzzle Award. The Thomas Jefferson Center's website says:
“[T]he First Amendment…guarantees the right of citizens ‘to petition the government for a redress of grievances.’ I missed the clause that says, ‘but bring your checkbook.’ ” - newspaper columnist Michael Paul Williams

For ordering the organizers of an unsuccessful petition to recall four County Supervisors and remove them from office to pay $80,000 of the Supervisors’ attorneys’ fees, a 2009 Jefferson Muzzle goes to Virginia Circuit Court Judge Westbrook J. Parker.

In July 2008, a special grand jury indicted four members of the Gloucester County Virginia Board of Supervisors on fourteen misdemeanor charges of malfeasance and misuse of office. In response, forty county residents organized an effort to have the four supervisors removed from office. Calling themselves “Gloucester County Citizens for Accountable Representation,” the group collected over six thousand signatures, many more than is required under Virginia law to initiate the formal process by which a judge determines if removal is appropriate.
Read the rest of the award here.

Saturday, February 07, 2009

Tax revolt: Gloucester, Bath, Augusta counties

Outrageous real estate assessments are not unique to Augusta County. Neighboring Bath County reassessed in April 2008 and had a revolt by citizens that resulted in terminating the appraisal company and doing away with the overly-inflated appraisals.

Gloucester County also had a tax revolt by its citizens after outrageous assessments in 2005 resulted in the Board of Supervisors passing by only one vote an agreement to pay the appraisal company.

In October 2007 the DailyPress.com wrote Why was this shack assessed at $43,700 while a mansion was valued at $0? Inside Gloucester's latest reassessment — and it's not a pretty picture.

The article began:
Bob Hicks asked the real estate assessor hired by Gloucester County if he'd actually set foot on the York River islands before setting their value at more than $150,000.

Hicks knew the answer would be "No."

While Gloucester's land book said the islands, acquired by Hicks' grandfather in 1927, totaled 188 acres, Hicks knew what apparently the assessor did not:

The islands don't exist anymore. Over the decades, the river had pretty much swallowed them. The land today is "valueless," Hicks told county officials in a successful protest of the assessment.

Hicks' experience was not unusual or even among the most significant of what turned into myriad problems emerging from the 2005 reassessment of Gloucester County real estate.
The Gloucester County Board of Equilization stepped in:
In a report published after concluding its work, the Gloucester County Board of Equalization — a panel appointed by the Circuit Court after every reassessment to correct disparities in the new valuations — was highly critical of the private contractor whose firm did the reassessment. It blasted Blue Ridge Mass Appraisal for flubbing the job, and suggested the company may have fudged the results.

In his turn, the firm's president, David Hickey, denies that Blue Ridge cut any corners during the reassessment. Hickey claims his work was hampered by poorly maintained county land records and says Commissioner of the Revenue Kevin Wilson deliberately withheld essential information from the assessors. Even the Gloucester County Board of Equalization came under fire from business owners who objected when the board fixed higher values on their properties than they thought was fair.

The Gloucester Board of Supervisors, which was warned at the start that Gloucester was hiring the "lesser of two evils" to do the reassessment, ended up deeply divided over whether to pay Blue Ridge or reject its work. The 4-3 vote to pay the firm, said then-Chairwoman Louise Theberge, reflected the board majority's desire to put the matter to rest.
Was there discontent with the four supervisors who voted in the majority?
Ultimately Gloucester softened the original sticker shock of the inflated revaluation — a jump that averaged 80 percent — by lowering its real estate tax rate from 95 cents to 57 cents per $100 of assessed value.

In a 4-3 vote, the supervisors defeated a move to lower the rate to 53 cents, which would have nearly equaled the pre-reassessment tax bills.
Today comes this interesting tidbit from WHSV TV-3 out of Harrisonburg:
The House of Delegates has passed legislation that would prohibit judges from sanctioning citizens who petition for the removal of public officials.

Without debate, the House passed Republican Del. Harvey Morgan's bill 93-3 Friday.

Morgan is from Gloucester County, where a judge recently ordered a group of citizens to pay $80,000 in legal fees after they unsuccessfully sought to remove four county supervisors from office.

Circuit Judge Westbrook J. Parker's order outraged free-speech advocacy groups, which have vowed to support the petitioners' appeal to the Virginia Supreme Court.

The judge said the petitioners misused the judicial process for political gain.
In the eastern part of the Commonwealth, DJ McGuire at the Right-Wing Liberal wrote What if you held a tax revolt and EVERYBODY came:
From what I can tell (thanks to WVN), the only penalty Augusta would face from suspending assessments one year would be $38,000 in lost dividend payments from Alcoholic Beverage Control. Given that the state shouldn’t be in the hard liquor business anyway, the Augusta BOS can chalk that up to the price of free-market principles, suspend all assessments, and find a firm that doesn’t take a year and a half to determine property values. From there, do assessments every two years, rather than four.

The above plan would thus have everyone assessed at the same temporal point in the market, and the new cycle would prevent things like this from having a lasting impact. As it is, the poor souls who had their property checked in the summer of 2007 would be stuck with a laughable assessment until 2013.

The question is, will the Board of Supervisors (especially the four Republicans who make up the majority) join with the lone Democrat - Tracy Pyles, who continues to make my late grandfather proud - and do what is right? Or are they blinded by the revenue windfall?

We will see. We will all see. As I’ve mentioned before, Augusta is a test case. If a county this Republican gets whacked with a tax hike, counties and cities all around the Commonwealth will use it as an example to browbeat their taxpaying constituents into submission.

That cannot be allowed to happen.
The eyes of Virginia are on Augusta County.